| 1730 | Col Thomas Marshall |
| 1737 | John May |
| 1753 | Miles Withers Conway |
| 1755 | Simon Kenton |
| 1757 | General Henry Lee |
| 1757 | Marquis de Lafayette |
| 1761 | Arthur Fox |
| 1761 | Capt Thomas Marshall |
| 1762 | John Coburn |
| 1766 | Basil Duke |
| 1767 | William Goforth |
| 1780 | John Chambers |
| 1788 | James A Paxton |
| 1788 | Col. Marshall Key |
| 1797 | Lewis Collins |
| 1801 | Richard Henry Lee Sr |
| 1803 | Albert Sidney Johnston |
| 1804 | John McClung |
| 1811 | Harriet Beecher Stowe |
| 1812 | Thornton Blackburn |
| 1817 | Maj John James Key |
| 1818 | Rev Elisha W. Green |
| 1819 | Col Thomas Marshall Key |
| 1824 | General Will "Bull" Nelson |
| 1846 | General William Louis Marshall |
| 1850 | Andrew Jackson Warner |
| 1851 | Lucy Bentley Marshall |
| 1869 | Eleanor Duncan Wood |